Medicare Advantage Plans 2027 Comparison
Comparing 2027 Medicare Advantage plans side by side is the only way to see which one actually fits your doctors, your prescriptions, and your budget – because two plans in the very same ZIP code can differ by thousands of dollars a year.
Here’s exactly what to compare, and how to line the plans up so the right one is easy to spot.
These are the factors that decide your real cost and quality of care. Weigh every plan against all of them – not just the premium:
✔
Monthly premium – many Medicare Advantage plans are $0, but $0 doesn’t always mean the lowest total cost.
✔
Maximum out-of-pocket (MOOP) – the yearly cap that protects you if you get sick. Lower is better.
✔
Provider network – confirm your doctors and hospitals are in-network. HMO vs PPO makes a big difference here.
✔
Prescription drug coverage (Part D) – check each plan’s formulary for your specific medications and their tiers.
✔
Extra benefits – dental, vision, hearing, OTC allowance, fitness, and transportation vary widely from plan to plan.
✔
CMS Star Rating – Medicare’s 1–5 quality score. A 4+ rating signals a well-run plan. See our full guide to the Medicare Advantage star ratings for what the score measures and where each carrier stands.
✔
Plan type & rules – HMO, PPO, PFFS, or a Special Needs Plan (SNP), and whether referrals or prior authorization are required (see the chart below).
How to Compare Medicare Advantage Plans 2027 Side by Side
1
Enter your ZIP code on this page to show 2027 plans available in your county.
2
Filter by what matters most to you – $0 premium, a specific carrier, or plan type.
3
Line the plans up on the factors above: premium, MOOP, network, drugs, extras, and star rating.
4
Confirm your doctors are in-network and your prescriptions are on the formulary.
5
Compare the total estimated yearly cost – not just the monthly premium – then check the star rating.
Medicare’s own comparison tool is where a lot of people start, and it is worth knowing both what it does well and where it leaves you on your own. Our guide to the Medicare Plan Finder tool covers the settings that quietly change your results, the gaps it does not cover, and the checks you still have to make yourself before enrolling.
Availability and cost vary enormously by state and county, which is why a national comparison only takes you so far. Florida is the clearest example, with one of the largest and most competitive markets in the country — our guide to Medicare Advantage plans in Florida covers which carriers compete there and how coverage differs between the metros and the rural counties.
California is the other end of the same lesson. It has more Medicare Advantage members than any state in the country, about 3.68 million, yet it sits almost exactly at the national median on how often people choose Advantage over Original Medicare. Our guide to Medicare Advantage plans in California covers the carriers competing there, the two separate Blue plans that confuse people every year, and why plan counts swing from more than a hundred in Los Angeles County down to zero in two counties.
Some states are shaped by history rather than size. Medicare Advantage plans in Minnesota show how far a single state can diverge — Minnesota runs ahead of the national enrollment average, has its own Medicare Supplement rules under a federal waiver, and is the one state where Medicare Cost plans were a dominant product before they were largely eliminated in 2018.
Ohio is the case for the opposite problem. The average Ohio beneficiary can choose from around 62 Medicare Advantage plans, one of the highest figures in the country, which turns the exercise from finding a plan into filtering out 61 of them. Our guide to Medicare Advantage plans in Ohio covers the regional carriers tied to each metro health system, and a gap in Ohio law that leaves 270,000 beneficiaries without any Medicare Supplement option at all.
Pennsylvania is the clearest example of a state that behaves like three separate markets. Roughly 1.6 million Pennsylvanians are in an Advantage plan, close to 58 percent, but which carriers compete for you depends entirely on where you live — western counties are dominated by health systems that own both the hospitals and the insurance plan, the Philadelphia region is a separate competitive market, and the central and northern tiers have noticeably thinner choices. Our guide to Medicare Advantage plans in Pennsylvania covers all three and why hospital affiliation matters more than premium there.
In the mid-Atlantic, upstate New York and Pennsylvania, regional carriers compete head to head with the national names. Compare CareFirst Medicare Advantage plans 2027 across Maryland and Washington, D.C., Excellus Medicare Advantage plans 2027 across Rochester, Central New York and the North Country, CDPHP Medicare Advantage plans 2027 in the Capital Region, UPMC Medicare Advantage plans 2027 in western Pennsylvania, and Geisinger Medicare Advantage plans 2027 in central and north-eastern Pennsylvania.
Carrier names change too. Cigna no longer sells Medicare plans under its own name — if you held a Cigna plan or are seeing the HealthSpring name for the first time, here is what happened to Cigna Medicare and who runs those plans now.
In Minnesota and western Wisconsin, the local plan to weigh against the national carriers is HealthPartners, which sells PPO plans only and still offers old-style Medicare Cost plans in seven Wisconsin counties. See HealthPartners Medicare Advantage plans 2027.
Use the quick reference below to see how the 2027 plan types stack up, then compare the plans in your area by ZIP code or call a licensed insurance agent at 1-855-454-9051 (TTY 711).