Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051

TTY user 711 Mon-Fri : 8am-9pm EST

Worst Medicare Advantage Plans 2027: Lowest Star Ratings and How to Choose a Better Plan

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated October 21, 2026

The best way to judge whether a Medicare Advantage plan is one of the “worst” is its CMS star rating. Medicare rates every plan contract from 1 to 5 stars each October based on quality, member experience and customer service.

The good news for 2027: low-rated plans are rare. Only 32 of 508 Medicare Advantage drug plan contracts scored below 3 stars, and about 71% of enrollees are in contracts rated 4 stars or higher. This guide shows how to spot a low-rated plan and choose a better one during Annual Enrollment, October 15 to December 7, 2026.

✔ Licensed across all 50 states✔ Built on CMS 2027 data✔ No-cost plan comparison

Compare Top-Rated 2027 Medicare Advantage Plans

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Agent 08
Worst Medicare Advantage plans 2027 by star rating: 508 MA-PD contracts rated, 71% of enrollees in 4+ star plans, 32 contracts below 3 stars, 4 low performing icon contracts

2027 Medicare Advantage Star Ratings at a Glance

Here is how CMS rated Medicare Advantage plans with drug coverage (MA-PD contracts) for 2027:

Measure 2027 Result
MA-PD contracts rated 508
Enrollment-weighted average rating 3.99 stars (4.01 in 2026)
Contracts rated 4 stars or higher 188 (about 37%)
Enrollees in 4-star-or-higher contracts About 71%
5-star contracts 15
Contracts below 3 stars 32 (31 at 2.5 stars, 1 at 2 stars)
Low performing icon contracts 4

Source: CMS 2027 Medicare Advantage and Part D Star Ratings fact sheet (Oct. 8, 2026).

Fewer than 1% of enrollees are in contracts rated below 3 stars, when weighted by enrollment. See the full results in our guide to the 2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings.

2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings distribution: 188 contracts at 4 stars or higher, 288 at 3 to 3.5 stars, 32 below 3 stars, 4 with the low performing icon

Which Medicare Advantage Plans Are Rated Lowest for 2027?

CMS flags a contract with a low performing icon when it has scored below 3 stars for three years in a row. These four contracts carry the icon for 2027:

Contract ID Contract Name Parent Organization
H3814 Atrio Health Plans ATRIO Health Plans
H4982 Aetna Better Health of California Inc. CVS Health Corporation
H7389 HealthSpring Life & Health Insurance Company, Inc. Health Care Service Corporation
H9066 Visiting Nurse Association of Central New York Visiting Nurse Association of Central New York

Source: CMS 2027 Star Ratings fact sheet, Table A2. Ratings apply to contracts, and one contract can include several plans.

A low rating applies to a specific contract, not to every plan a company sells. The same carrier can have highly rated contracts in other states, so always check the rating of the exact plan you are considering.

What a Low Star Rating Can Mean for You

✔

Weaker quality scores on measures such as preventive screenings and managing chronic conditions.

✔

Lower member satisfaction with getting care, customer service or the drug plan.

✔

Fewer extra benefits over time. Plans rated 4 stars or higher earn quality bonus payments that many use for richer benefits.

✔

Medicare warnings. Medicare.gov displays the low performing icon, and you may get a notice if your plan has it.

If you’re in a contract with a low performing icon, you may be able to switch to a higher-rated plan using a Special Enrollment Period. Ask Medicare or a licensed agent whether you qualify.

How to Avoid a Low-Rated Medicare Advantage Plan

1

Check the overall star rating of every plan you compare. Aim for 4 stars or higher when you can.

2

Look for the low performing icon on Medicare.gov and steer clear of contracts that have it.

3

Compare your total yearly cost: premium, copays, the out-of-pocket maximum and drug costs.

4

Confirm your doctors and hospitals are in the plan’s network.

5

Read your Annual Notice of Change if you’re already enrolled, to see what’s changing for 2027.

Start with our list of top-rated Medicare Advantage plans and our picks for the best Medicare Advantage plans for 2027.

The Highest-Rated Medicare Advantage Plans for 2027

Fifteen Medicare Advantage drug plan contracts earned 5 stars for 2027, including contracts from UnitedHealthcare, Kaiser Permanente, Anthem, Clover Health, Longevity Health Plan, Leon Health, Peak Health, MCS Advantage and Triple-S. A 5-star plan also gives you a special chance to switch into it once during the year.

Every year, most enrollees end up in highly rated plans. In 2027, about 71% of Medicare Advantage drug plan enrollees are in contracts rated 4 stars or more, so finding a strong plan in your area is usually possible.

How to Choose a Better Plan for 2027

✔

Shop during Annual Enrollment, October 15 to December 7, 2026, for coverage that starts January 1, 2027.

✔

Use the star rating as a tiebreaker between plans with similar costs and networks.

✔

Consider low-cost options such as $0 premium Medicare Advantage plans, but check the rating and out-of-pocket maximum too.

✔

Know the trade-offs. Read our guide to the disadvantages of Medicare Advantage plans and how to avoid them.

Compare Top-Rated 2027 Medicare Advantage Plans

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Agent 08

Worst Medicare Advantage Plans — Frequently Asked Questions

➤ What are the worst Medicare Advantage plans for 2027?

By CMS star ratings, the lowest-rated are the 32 MA-PD contracts scored below 3 stars. Four of them carry the low performing icon for 2027: Atrio Health Plans (H3814), Aetna Better Health of California (H4982), HealthSpring Life & Health Insurance Company (H7389) and Visiting Nurse Association of Central New York (H9066).

➤ How many Medicare Advantage plans have low star ratings in 2027?

Only 32 of 508 Medicare Advantage drug plan contracts scored below 3 stars for 2027, about 6%. Weighted by enrollment, fewer than 1% of members are in those contracts.

➤ What is the low performing icon?

It is a warning Medicare shows on contracts that scored below 3 stars for three years in a row. Four contracts have the icon for 2027.

➤ What is the average Medicare Advantage star rating for 2027?

The enrollment-weighted average for Medicare Advantage drug plans is 3.99 stars for 2027, compared with 4.01 for 2026.

➤ Can I leave a low-rated Medicare Advantage plan?

Yes. You can switch during Annual Enrollment, October 15 to December 7. If your plan has the low performing icon, you may also qualify for a Special Enrollment Period.

➤ How many Medicare Advantage plans earned 5 stars for 2027?

Fifteen Medicare Advantage drug plan contracts earned 5 stars for 2027, including contracts from UnitedHealthcare, Kaiser Permanente, Anthem and Clover Health.

➤ Does a low star rating mean a plan is bad for me?

Not always. Ratings measure average quality and member experience. A plan can still fit you if your doctors are in network and the costs work, but a higher-rated plan is usually the safer choice.

➤ Where can I check a plan’s star rating?

Medicare.gov shows star ratings for every plan, and they appear when you compare plans by ZIP code. You can also see 2027 results in our star ratings guide.

New to Medicare?

If you are new to Medicare, then you can enroll in a 2027 Medicare Advantage plan up to three months prior to your Medicare Part B effective date.

Call one of our licensed insurance agents to see what the best time frame is for you to enroll, based on your current situation. You can contact them at 1-855-454-9051 (TTY 711), Mon–Fri 8am–9pm EST.

Have Questions?

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051

TTY users 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Compare plans & benefits in your area

Or speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Agent 08