Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051

TTY user 711 Mon-Fri : 8am-9pm EST

Healthfirst Medicare Advantage 2027: NYC, Long Island and Hudson Valley Plans

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 7, 2026

Healthfirst is a New York nonprofit insurer owned by a group of the city’s hospitals and health systems. Its Medicare Advantage plans are sold only in New York: the five boroughs, Nassau and Westchester, and parts of Long Island and the Hudson Valley.

Our count of CMS’s 2027 plan files finds 8 individual Healthfirst Medicare Advantage plans in 11 New York counties, including 3 plans for people with both Medicare and Medicaid. This guide sorts them by county and cost, and covers the 2027 rule changes Healthfirst has flagged for dual members. Annual Enrollment runs October 15 to December 7, 2026.

✔ Licensed across all 50 states✔ Built on CMS 2027 data✔ No-cost plan comparison

Compare Healthfirst Medicare Advantage Plans for 2027

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Agent 08
Healthfirst Medicare Advantage 2027: 8 plans (7 HMOs, 1 PPO) in 11 New York counties, including 3 dual special needs plans and 7 plans in each NYC borough

Healthfirst Plans by County for 2027

Which Healthfirst plans you can buy depends heavily on the county. The NYC plans and the Hudson Valley version of Signature are filed under different contracts:

Plan Type 2027 counties
Healthfirst 65 Plus Plan HMO Bronx, Kings, New York, Queens, Richmond, Nassau, Westchester
Healthfirst Increased Benefits Plan HMO All 11 counties, including Suffolk, Rockland, Orange and Sullivan
Healthfirst Signature (H5989) HMO The five boroughs and Nassau
Healthfirst Signature (H1722) HMO Westchester, Rockland, Orange, Sullivan
Healthfirst Signature (H9678) PPO Five boroughs, Nassau, Westchester, Rockland, Suffolk
Life Improvement Plan HMO D-SNP All 11 counties
CompleteCare HMO D-SNP 10 counties (not Suffolk)
Connection Plan HMO D-SNP 10 counties (not Suffolk)

Source: our analysis of CMS 2027 Plan Benefit Package and plan service area data, contracts H3359, H5989, H1722 and H9678, individual plans.

In Suffolk County, only three Healthfirst plans are filed for 2027: Increased Benefits, Signature PPO and Life Improvement.

Our Analysis: What the CMS Files Show

Our analysis of CMS 2027 plan data

✔

8 plans, 11 counties, one state. 7 HMOs and 1 PPO; Healthfirst Signature (PPO) is the only Healthfirst plan with out-of-network coverage.

✔

3 of 8 plans are dual special needs plans (Life Improvement, CompleteCare and Connection), for people with Medicare and Medicaid.

✔

7 plans in each borough. In the Bronx, Healthfirst files 7 of 70 individual plans, level with UnitedHealthcare (7) and behind Aetna (11) and ahead of Anthem (5) and Elderplan (4).

✔

Thin upstate: just 5 Healthfirst plans in Orange and Sullivan counties and 3 in Suffolk.

Compare Healthfirst Medicare Advantage Plans for 2027

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Agent 08
Bronx Medicare Advantage carriers 2027: Aetna 11, Wellcare 10, Healthfirst 7, UnitedHealthcare 7, Anthem BCBS 5, Elderplan 4, EmblemHealth 3, Humana 3, MetroPlus 3

What Healthfirst Plans Cost in 2027

Third-party listings of CMS’s 2027 data show a wide spread between Healthfirst’s $0 HMO and its PPO:

Plan Monthly premium Medical deductible Drug deductible In-network maximum
65 Plus Plan (HMO) H3359-001 $0 $0 $700 $9,850
Signature (HMO) H5989-011 $60 $0 $550 $9,850
Signature (PPO) H9678-002 $155 $450 $700 $9,850

Source: Medicare.org and MedicarePlans.com listings of CMS 2027 data, retrieved November 7, 2026. You also pay your Part B premium.

All three list a $0 primary care copay in network. The PPO adds out-of-network care at a $50 primary care copay and $75 specialist copay. Listings show 3.5 stars for the 65 Plus Plan’s contract and 3.0 stars for both Signature contracts for 2027; Healthfirst had announced 4.5 stars for its plans in October 2025, so check the 2027 rating for your plan ID in Medicare Plan Finder.

2027 changes for dual members

Healthfirst says that from January 1, 2027, Medicaid recipients will need to recertify every six months and some will face work requirements; it says these do not apply to dual members 65 and older. It also says new, stricter rules apply to the OTC Plus card on its dual plans: the card still works for over-the-counter items, but using it for food and utilities requires a qualifying chronic condition such as diabetes or a cardiovascular disorder. Healthfirst also warns that some drug copays and deductibles may rise.

Who Healthfirst Fits

A good fit if you:

✔

Live in New York City, Nassau or Westchester and use a Healthfirst-network hospital

✔

Have Medicare and Medicaid and want a dual plan

✔

Want a $0 premium HMO and mostly in-network care

✔

Need a PPO in NYC and are willing to pay a premium for it

Look harder at other options if you:

!

Live outside the 11 counties, including most of upstate New York

!

Spend part of the year in another state, since most Healthfirst plans are HMOs

!

Want a low out-of-pocket maximum; sample 2027 plans list $9,850

Compare Healthfirst with Aetna, UnitedHealthcare, Anthem, EmblemHealth and the other companies in your borough.

Before You Enroll in Healthfirst for 2027

1

Check your county against the plan table; Signature is three different plans depending on where you live.

2

Confirm your hospital and doctors are in the 2027 Healthfirst network.

3

Read your 2027 Annual Notice of Change for drug copay and deductible changes.

4

Dual members: check whether the new OTC Plus card rules affect you and whether your doctor needs to complete an attestation form.

5

Compare the out-of-pocket maximum, not just the premium.

6

Enroll by December 7, 2026. See all your options in our New York Medicare Advantage guide.

Compare Healthfirst Medicare Advantage Plans for 2027

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Agent 08

Healthfirst Medicare Advantage 2027 — Frequently Asked Questions

➤ Where are Healthfirst Medicare Advantage plans sold in 2027?

Only in New York. CMS’s 2027 files list Healthfirst plans in Bronx, Kings, New York, Queens, Richmond, Nassau, Suffolk, Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Sullivan counties.

➤ How many Healthfirst Medicare Advantage plans are there for 2027?

Our count finds 8 individual plans: 4 regular HMOs, 1 PPO and 3 dual special needs HMOs.

➤ Does Healthfirst have a $0 premium plan for 2027?

Yes. Listings of CMS’s 2027 data show the Healthfirst 65 Plus Plan (HMO) with a $0 monthly premium; you still pay your Part B premium.

➤ Does Healthfirst have a PPO?

Yes. Healthfirst Signature (PPO), H9678-002, is filed in nine counties for 2027. Listings show a $155 monthly premium and a $450 medical deductible.

➤ Why are there three Healthfirst Signature plans?

Signature is sold under three contracts: an HMO for the five boroughs and Nassau, an HMO for Westchester, Rockland, Orange and Sullivan, and a PPO across nine counties. Each has its own costs.

➤ What is changing with the Healthfirst OTC Plus card in 2027?

Healthfirst says stricter rules apply on its dual plans: using the card for food and utilities requires a qualifying chronic condition. It can still be used for over-the-counter items.

➤ Is Healthfirst sold in Suffolk County?

Yes, but only three plans for 2027: Increased Benefits (HMO), Signature (PPO) and Life Improvement (HMO D-SNP).

➤ Who owns Healthfirst?

Healthfirst is a nonprofit health plan owned by New York hospitals and health systems.

New to Medicare?

If you are new to Medicare, then you can enroll in a 2027 Medicare Advantage plan up to three months prior to your Medicare Part B effective date.

Call one of our licensed insurance agents to see what the best time frame is for you to enroll, based on your current situation. You can contact them at 1-855-454-9051 (TTY 711), Mon–Fri 8am–9pm EST.

Have Questions?

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051

TTY users 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Compare plans & benefits in your area

Or speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Agent 08