Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051

TTY user 711 Mon-Fri : 8am-9pm EST

Independent Health Medicare Advantage 2027: Buffalo and Western New York Plans

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 11, 2026

Independent Health started in 1980 as a University at Buffalo graduate school project and still sells health plans mainly in Western New York. Its press releases describe it as Williamsville-based, it reports nearly 325,000 members across all lines of business, and Candid (GuideStar) lists Independent Health Association, Inc. of Buffalo as a nonprofit.

For Medicare, the footprint is tight. Our count of CMS’s 2027 plan files finds 7 individual Independent Health Medicare Advantage plans, sold only in 8 Western New York counties: Erie, Niagara, Chautauqua, Cattaraugus, Allegany, Genesee, Orleans and Wyoming. Six are HMOs and one is a PPO. Below we list every 2027 plan, show sample costs pulled from listings of CMS data, and compare Independent Health with the other companies selling in Erie County.

✔ Licensed across all 50 states✔ Built on CMS 2027 data✔ No-cost plan comparison

Compare Independent Health Medicare Plans for 2027

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Agent 08
Independent Health Medicare Advantage 2027: 7 plans (6 HMOs, 1 PPO) in 8 Western New York counties, 7 of Erie County's 60 plans, listed 4.5-star rating

The 2027 Independent Health Lineup, Plan by Plan

Plan Type WNY counties What sets it apart
Encompass 65 RED 042 HMO 8 Lowest-premium RED version with Part D in our sample
Encompass 65 RED 044 HMO 8 Higher premium, lower $8,000 maximum
Encompass 65 RED 045 HMO 8 New contract number for 2027; replaces RED 043
Encompass 65 HMO 8 No Part D drug coverage; Part B premium reduction
Medicare Passport Connect PPO 8 The only plan that pays out of network
Medicare Family Choice HMO I-SNP 8 Institutional special needs plan
Assure Advantage HMO C-SNP 1 (Erie) For people with chronic heart failure

Source: our analysis of CMS 2027 Plan Benefit Package and plan service area files, contracts H3362 (HMO) and H3344 (PPO), individual plans. Plan details from MedicarePlans.com and Medicare.org listings of CMS 2027 data and Independent Health’s 2026 plan list.

The lineup is almost the same as 2026, with one swap. Independent Health’s 2026 plan page lists Encompass 65 RED 042, 043 and 044. CMS’s 2027 files no longer include RED 043 and add RED 045 in the same 8 counties. If you have RED 043 today, read your Annual Notice of Change to see which plan you will be moved to, and compare it with the other RED versions before December 7.

Assure Advantage is the only plan that stops at the Erie County line. Everywhere else in the region, residents see 6 Independent Health plans; Erie County residents see all 7.

Erie County NY Medicare Advantage carriers 2027: Wellcare 10, UnitedHealthcare 9, Aetna 9, Independent Health 7, Univera (Excellus) 7, Highmark 6, MVP Health Care 3, Humana 3

How Independent Health Stacks Up in Erie County

Our analysis of CMS 2027 plan data

✔

Erie County (Buffalo) has 60 individual Medicare Advantage plans for 2027. Independent Health files 7 of them, about one in nine. UnitedHealthcare and Aetna file 9 each, Univera (Excellus) 7 and Highmark 6.

✔

All 7 Independent Health plans are sold only in Western New York. New York has 224 individual Medicare Advantage plans for 2027; none of Independent Health’s reach east of Wyoming and Allegany counties.

✔

Independent Health files no dual special needs plan (D-SNP) for 2027. Erie County has 16 D-SNPs, all from other companies, so people with both Medicare and Medicaid will look elsewhere for that kind of plan.

✔

Two of its 7 plans are special needs plans: Medicare Family Choice (institutional) in all 8 counties and Assure Advantage (chronic heart failure) in Erie only.

Buffalo is a two-local-plan market. Independent Health and Univera, the Western New York brand of Excellus BlueCross BlueShield, both build their HMOs around area doctors and hospitals. Highmark, which sells Blue plans here as well, is a third regional option. Compare all three in our guides to Excellus and Univera Medicare Advantage and Highmark Medicare Advantage.

Compare Independent Health Medicare Plans for 2027

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Agent 08

What Independent Health Plans Cost in 2027

Plan Monthly premium In-network max Specialist Hospital stay Drug deductible
Encompass 65 (HMO), H3362-016 $0 $6,750 $30 $300/day, days 1-5 No Part D
Encompass 65 RED 042 (HMO), H3362-042 $49 $9,850 $55 $530/day, days 1-4 $550
Encompass 65 RED 044 (HMO), H3362-044 $110 $8,000 $35 $425/day, days 1-5 $510
Medicare Passport Connect (PPO), H3344-013 $81 $9,850 $55 $450/day, days 1-5 $700
Assure Advantage (HMO C-SNP), H3362-040 $15 $8,500 See plan See plan $250

Source: MedicarePlans.com and Medicare.org listings of CMS 2027 plan data, retrieved November 11, 2026. Primary care is listed at $0 on the four non-SNP plans. RED 045 costs were not available to us.

The spread is wide. Encompass 65 has the lowest maximum, $6,750, and lists a $60 monthly Part B premium reduction, but it has no drug coverage, so it only makes sense if you get drugs through the VA, TRICARE or a retiree plan. Among the plans with Part D, RED 044 costs the most each month and caps your yearly in-network spending lowest, at $8,000.

Passport Connect costs more in 2027 than in 2026. Medicare.org listed it at $58.80 a month with a $9,250 maximum for 2026; the 2027 listing shows $81 and $9,850. The tradeoff for that premium is out-of-network coverage, which 2026 listings showed at 50% coinsurance for most services.

From 5 stars to 4.5 in the listings

Independent Health announced that its Medicare HMO plans were rated 5 stars for 2026 and its PPO 4.5 stars, and called itself the only Western New York insurer with a 5-star Medicare Advantage plan for 2026. Listings of CMS 2027 data show 4.5 stars for both contracts. A 4.5-star rating is still high, but the 5-star special enrollment period, which lets you switch into a 5-star plan during the year, would not apply.

Extras Listed on Independent Health Plans

✔

Dental: listings for the plans we checked show $0 exams, X-rays and cleanings, with 50% coinsurance for fillings, root canals, gum care and extractions. Implants and orthodontics are not covered.

✔

Vision: $0 routine eye exam and $0 eyeglasses or contacts are listed; check the yearly allowance in the Evidence of Coverage.

✔

Hearing: prescription hearing aids are listed at $499 to $1,949 per aid, with a $45 fitting.

✔

Drugs: every plan except Encompass 65 includes Part D, and 2027 out-of-pocket drug costs are capped at $2,400.

These benefits may differ between plan versions. Confirm details in each 2027 Summary of Benefits before you enroll.

Is Independent Health a Good Match?

A good fit if you:

✔

Live in one of the 8 Western New York counties it serves

✔

See doctors who already take Independent Health

✔

Want a plan rated 4.5 stars or higher in listings

✔

Have heart failure and live in Erie County (Assure Advantage)

Look harder at other options if you:

!

Have Medicaid too and want a D-SNP

!

Spend part of the year outside Western New York and want an HMO

!

Want a $0 premium plan with drug coverage; our sample did not find one

See the full statewide picture in our guide to Medicare Advantage plans in New York.

Before You Pick an Independent Health Plan

1

Decide whether you need Part D in the plan. Encompass 65 has none; skipping drug coverage without other creditable coverage can bring a late penalty.

2

Weigh premium against the yearly cap. In our sample, monthly premiums run $0 to $110 and maximums $6,750 to $9,850.

3

Choose HMO or PPO. Only Passport Connect pays for out-of-network care.

4

If you are on RED 043, check your Annual Notice of Change for your 2027 plan.

5

Enroll by December 7, 2026 for coverage that starts January 1, 2027.

Compare Independent Health Medicare Plans for 2027

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Agent 08

Independent Health Medicare 2027 — Frequently Asked Questions

➤ Is Independent Health a nonprofit?

Candid (GuideStar) lists Independent Health Association, Inc. of Buffalo as a nonprofit. The company says it began in 1980 as a University at Buffalo graduate school project.

➤ Which counties can enroll in Independent Health Medicare plans for 2027?

CMS’s 2027 files list Erie, Niagara, Chautauqua, Cattaraugus, Allegany, Genesee, Orleans and Wyoming counties in New York.

➤ How many Medicare Advantage plans does Independent Health sell for 2027?

Our count finds 7 individual plans: 4 Encompass 65 HMOs (three RED versions and one without drugs), the Passport Connect PPO and two special needs plans.

➤ What happened to Encompass 65 RED 043?

It appears on Independent Health’s 2026 plan list but not in CMS’s 2027 files, which add RED 045 instead. Members should check their Annual Notice of Change.

➤ What is the cheapest Independent Health plan in 2027?

Encompass 65 (HMO) lists a $0 premium and a $60 monthly Part B reduction, but no drug coverage. Of the drug plans we checked, RED 042 lists the lowest premium at $49.

➤ Does Independent Health cover me out of network?

Only Medicare Passport Connect, the PPO, pays for out-of-network care. The HMOs generally cover emergencies and urgent care only outside the network.

➤ Who qualifies for Assure Advantage?

Listings describe it as a chronic condition special needs plan for chronic heart failure, sold only in Erie County for 2027.

➤ What star rating does Independent Health have for 2027?

Listings of CMS 2027 data show 4.5 stars for contracts H3362 and H3344. For 2026, the company reported 5 stars for its HMOs and 4.5 for its PPO.

New to Medicare?

If you are new to Medicare, then you can enroll in a 2027 Medicare Advantage plan up to three months prior to your Medicare Part B effective date.

Call one of our licensed insurance agents to see what the best time frame is for you to enroll, based on your current situation. You can contact them at 1-855-454-9051 (TTY 711), Mon–Fri 8am–9pm EST.

Have Questions?

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051

TTY users 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Compare plans & benefits in your area

Or speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-454-9051TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Agent 08